What could better breeding be worth to UK sheep and beef? A 10-year vision for genetic improvement

Prepared for Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) and Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board (AHDB)AHDB Published October 2022

Genetic improvement already adds value to UK sheep and beef farms, but the systems that deliver it are fragmented. Defra and AHDB asked AbacusBio to build the evidence base for a future national programme that serves both farm profitability and climate goals.

Texel sheep grazing
Fig. 1. UK sheep.
At a glance
ClientDefra and AHDB
ScopeHistoric and future benefits of breeding, 35 industry interviews, 4 programme options, cost-benefit analysis
Headline resultBenefit-cost ratios of 8:1 to 18:1 for sheep and 4:1 to 6:1 for beef
Output12 recommendations to guide business planning

The challenge

AHDB, Defra and their stakeholders share a long-term vision: that genetic improvement drives a step change in the economic and environmental performance of UK sheep and beef. Getting there needs coordinated performance recording and genetic evaluation, good national data, and active research and knowledge exchange.

The sector faces real pressure. Farmers told us their biggest challenges over the next decade are net zero and wider environmental impact, tighter margins as subsidies fall away, and recruiting and keeping staff.

Current genetic services are split across several providers. Selection pressure across the industry is low. Before committing to a new model, Defra and AHDB needed answers to three questions:

  • What have genetics delivered so far, and what could they deliver in future, in both economic and environmental terms?
  • What kind of national genetic improvement programme would suit the UK best?
  • Would a national programme to collect phenotypes and genotypes pay for itself?

Gene editing and genetic modification were outside the scope.

Our approach

The work was split into three work packages.

1. Historic and future benefits

We used deterministic modelling to value the genetic gain already made in UK sheep and beef. We then used selection index theory to model a range of future scenarios. These included adding more core traits, adding feed intake and methane yield, using genomics across all traits, and increasing selection intensity and adoption. We reported economic benefits as net present value (NPV) and environmental benefits as enteric greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, in both gross and intensity (per kg of carcase) terms. From this we defined metrics to track progress.

2. Industry consultation and programme options

We interviewed 35 people across breeding companies, levy boards, farmers, livestock specialists, food service and retail, and breed societies. Together with a review of international programmes, this told us what “good” looks like. We then built four options, from small improvements to a full overhaul:

  • A. Status quo supported by R&D
  • B. National infrastructure on an existing platform
  • C. National infrastructure on a new UK platform
  • D. Full national programme with integrated infrastructure

External experts weighted a range of criteria and scored each option for value to industry and ease of delivery.

3. Cost-benefit analysis

We costed a national phenotype and genotype collection programme built around central reference herds and flocks and a structured progeny test. We then compared those costs with the modelled benefits.

What we found

Breeding already pays. Historic genetic gain will deliver annualised benefits of £14.7m for sheep (NPV of £183m over 20 years) and £6.8m for beef (NPV of £84m). It also cuts emissions: about 0.1% a year in gross terms for sheep and 0.08% for beef.

There is much more to gain. Over 30 years, future economic benefits range from £328.1m to £978.8m for sheep, and from £182m to £291.3m for beef. The highest values come from full-scale genomics combined with higher selection intensity and wider adoption.

Core traits matter more than new ones, for now. Selecting on a broader set of core traits cut emissions more than adding feed intake and methane yield did. There are two reasons. Current indexes select on economic outcomes only, but the drivers of economic and environmental efficiency overlap. Feed intake and methane yield are also predicted with lower accuracy and raising that accuracy is likely to cost too much.

Industry is ready for change. Everyone we interviewed saw genetics as part of the solution. People want plain-English ratings of genetic merit linked to farm KPIs, a single independent data system, one national evaluation for each livestock type, and strong knowledge exchange. There was universal agreement to share data where it brings mutual benefit.

Options B and C offer the most value. Option C scored best overall. Option B also offered high value, and was almost as easy to deliver as option A. Stakeholders saw less extra value in moving to option D.

A data collection programme would pay for itself several times over. Benefit-cost ratios ranged from 8:1 to 18:1 for sheep and from 4:1 to 6:1 for beef. We costed conservatively, so these ratios are likely to be low. Scenarios with higher selection intensity and adoption gave the best returns.

Recommendations

We made 12 recommendations. The main ones are:

  • Invest in a future programme, backed by a detailed business plan. The scale of benefit shows genetic improvement has a cornerstone role in the sustainability of UK sheep and beef.
  • Consult further on options B and C. Focus on the core providers of genetic evaluation in the UK, and set out how existing stakeholders would fit into the chosen model.
  • Use a clear set of metrics. Track the annual rate of economic genetic gain per mated female as the main measure, and split the environmental measure into gross and intensity terms.
  • Build indexes that balance GHG and economic outcomes before deciding how much to invest in feed intake and methane yield.
  • Focus the data collection programme on core selection index traits. These also help show the commercial value of genetics, improve links between herds and flocks, and support comparisons across breeds.
  • Look for savings by using existing datasets and sharing overheads across the sheep and beef programmes.
  • Plan for infrastructure. Forecast needs for feed intake and methane phenotypes exceed current capacity, so capital costs belong in the business plan.
  • Speak a common language. A single set of industry-wide indexes, backed by strong knowledge exchange, is needed to realise the gains from higher selection intensity and adoption.

What happens next

The report is the first step towards the long-term vision. It gives Defra and AHDB the evidence they need to develop a business plan for a national genetic improvement programme, and a set of metrics to measure its progress on profit and emissions.

Read the full report: A vision for improving the UK sheep and beef sectors through breeding over the next 10 years, prepared for Defra and AHDB.

How we can help

AbacusBio helps governments, levy bodies and breeding organisations design genetic improvement programmes and decide where to invest, using economic modelling, selection index design, stakeholder engagement and cost-benefit analysis. If you’re planning a national breeding programme, talk to our team.